Arctic
Char in Ireland; Angling Versus Conservation
Dr. Fran Igoe
Arctic char are probably Ireland's most underrated
and least well known
native sport angling species. Even though they are one of only
a handful
of indigenous species to Ireland and are closely related to the salmon
and
trout, both very popular with anglers, they remain a mystery to most
Irish
people. Ask anybody you know in Ireland (excluding fishery biologists
and some of the angling fraternity), what is an Arctic char and the
answer
will most likely surprise you, if you get one at all. In fact
the species is not
even listed within the Irish Specimen Year Book (a annual record of
trophy
sized fish and records). In some quarters the traditional view
has been that angling for this species (long recognised as being vulnerable
to extinction) was likely to put it in danger. Such opinions,
although noble and sometimes warranted, have little relevance in an
Irish context. There are no documented cases of negative effects
of angling for char on any Irish char population. In lakes where
they do occur, recent surveys by fishery authorities have shown that
they are present in very large numbers and there is no reason to see
why they could not sustain controlled angling pressure as in other
European countries, as in Lake Windermere in the English Lake District.
In fact many other problems or potential problems
have been noted in Irish char lakes, which could have a much greater
impact on the species, e.g., acidification, eutrophication, abstraction
of lake shore gravels, afforestation, stocking with non-indigenous
species, water abstraction, sedimentation pollution.
With the exception
of a few dedicated personnel in the various government agencies and
a small number of members of the public, the plight of char in Ireland
has gone largely unnoticed by both Irish Governments and the public
at large.
Therefore
one of the principal methods to achieve the objective of char conservation
in Ireland, is to promote angling for the species. Anglers have made
a very important contribution with regard to protection of our lakes
and rivers from pollution, and continue to put pressure at a local
and European level. Not only would anglers provide an important lobby
for the protection of char, but also enable monitoring of the species
through creel census data.
Angling for char in its own right is an enjoyable
sport and many of our corespondents from the international community
can vouch for the value of the species. With this in mind we have
provided a table of lakes where char have been caught by rod and line
in the past (mostly borrowed from information supplied by the great
Arthur Went with a few updates). Where possible details of fishing
method are provided. Furthermore, Myles Kelly hs distilled correspondence
he has received from our regular contributors (thanks to all!) and
has presented the information on fly fishing in a practical format
for people to try. We are enclosing a form which we encourage people
to fill if they do take up the challenge, so we can update our data
base and provide useful information to all.

What they said about our char!
'a most delicate fish.'
Camden G.W. (1789)on. L.Eske char
'The lough abounds with a most excellent kind
of fish called char.'
Seward (1795)
'Among other new sensations I had the pleasure
of catching my first char in a fine sheet of water known as Gort Glas,
which in english means, Green Lake.'
John Bikerdyke (1897) Wild sports of Ireland
'But the beauty of the lake is the red trout
or char.'
'The red trout is, however, by far the best
eating of all the lake breed.'
Yarrell (1841) on Melvin char
'...and charr which deemed & excellent
fish, pleasant to its taste, beautiful to ye eye.'
Cromwellian Civil Survey (1656)
'The char. We have these beautiful fish gold
and silver...'
O'Gorman (1845)
'...the flesh of the char is red and curdy
as a salmon and eats more delicious than any trout.'
Smith (1774)
Ba mhaith
libh dull ag iascaireacht anois?
(Would you like to go fishing now?)
Copyright
2003. ICCG ©2003
|